Garhwal Post Bureau
New Delhi/Haldwani, 18 Nov: The long-running dispute over the reported encroachment on railway land in Banbhulpura, Haldwani, once again remained unresolved today as the matter could not be taken up for hearing in the Supreme Court. The case concerns nearly 30 hectares of railway land and is closely linked to the future of thousands of families residing in the area who have encroached upon the railway land for long in Haldwani. Anticipating the hearing, the Nainital district police had deployed additional security personnel in Banbhulpura and other sensitive localities.
The Banbhulpura railway land dispute is not a recent controversy but a legal battle that has been continuing for nearly two decades. The issue dates back to 2007, when action was initiated against settlements located on land claimed by the Railways and the state government in the vicinity of Haldwani Railway Station. The Railways has consistently maintained that the land belongs to it and that the removal of encroachments is necessary for railway line expansion, station development and future rail infrastructure projects.
The dispute acquired a significant legal dimension during the hearing of a PIL related to illegal mining in the Gaula River, when the issue of alleged encroachment on railway land came under judicial scrutiny. Subsequently, a petition related to the matter was filed before the Nainital High Court in 2013. The Railways was made a party to the proceedings and submitted ownership documents and revenue records in support of its claim, seeking removal of encroachments from the land.
In 2016, the High Court had directed the removal of encroachments from railway land. Challenging the order, affected residents approached the Supreme Court. In 2017, the apex court directed that the affected parties be heard. During joint surveys conducted by the Railways and the administration, 4,365 alleged encroachments were identified in the area.
The issue resurfaced prominently after the Uttarakhand High Court, on 20 December, 2022, again ordered the removal of encroachments from the disputed land. The order triggered widespread concern among residents amid fears that thousands of families could face displacement. The matter was subsequently taken to the Supreme Court, which, on 5 January, 2023, stayed the High Court’s order and allowed the legal process to continue. Interestingly, the HC had quoted the SC’s general directions in its judgement while ordering eviction of the land.
The case has since witnessed several rounds of hearings. On 24 July, 2024, the SC directed the authorities to identify the disputed land, prepare details of affected families and formulate a rehabilitation plan. During subsequent proceedings, the Railways informed the court that approximately 30.65 hectares of land would be required for the Haldwani project. The court also directed authorities to organise camps for assessing the eligibility of affected families and facilitating applications under the Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana. It further ordered that the eligibility of residents be examined before any further action.
According to figures cited in the proceedings, the dispute involves nearly 30 hectares of railway land, around 3,500 structures and 5,236 families. It is estimated that the outcome of the case could directly impact about 27,000 people residing in the area. The matter was listed at serial number 118 in the Supreme Court today but it could not be heard during the day.
In view of the significance of the case, police and administrative authorities had made elaborate security arrangements in Banbhulpura and adjoining areas. Additional police personnel had been deployed and officers remained on alert to deal with any eventuality.

