By Arun Pratap Singh
Garhwal Post Bureau
Dehradun, 17 Nov: The controversy surrounding the alleged Rs 14 lakh robbery case in Dehradun’s Patel Nagar area has taken a fresh turn after SSP Pramendra Dobal suspended a constable whose purported video, containing serious allegations regarding the mistreatment of the accused by the Police, went viral on social media. While the police administration has initiated action against the constable, the contents of the alleged video have triggered wider questions about whether the focus of the investigation will remain limited to the policeman who spoke out or also extend to the allegations he purportedly made against a senior police officer.
The case has remained in the spotlight ever since the arrest of Bajrang Dal worker Sidhant Badoni in connection with the alleged robbery. Members of the organisation and supporters of the accused have repeatedly questioned the police action and alleged that Badoni and others arrested in the case were subjected to custodial torture. While it can’t be stated or confirmed that the allegations levelled by Bajrang Dal of false implication of Badoni are true, the fact remains that SHO Naresh Rathore has been in the news for wrong reasons in several other incidents as well. In another case, he has been also accused of threatening and false implication of a couple from the hills while he was posted at Premnagar. The allegations in this particular case levelled by Bajrang Dal gained further traction after a purported video of a constable posted at Patel Nagar Police Station began circulating widely on social media platforms.
In the viral clip, the constable is allegedly heard claiming that the arrested persons were subjected to inhuman treatment during interrogation. It may also be added here that some other people have also alleged torture of the accused by Patel Nagar Police in this case. In the viral video, the police constable is purportedly heard alleging that the alleged torture was carried out on the directions of police officer Naresh Rathore. The authenticity of the video and the allegations contained in it have not been independently verified, and police have maintained that all claims are being investigated.
However, the decision of SSP Pramendra Dobal to suspend Constable Praveen Kumar after the video came to light has itself become a subject of public debate. While police officials maintain that disciplinary action was taken because the conduct of the constable was under scrutiny, critics and several social media users have questioned why immediate action was visible against the constable while no corresponding action has yet been announced against the officer named in the alleged video. The development has led to growing speculation online about whether the Dehradun Police are more concerned with identifying and penalising the source of the allegations rather than addressing the allegations themselves.
City SP Shekhar Suyal confirmed that Constable Praveen Kumar, posted at Kotwali Patel Nagar, had been suspended and that the video was under investigation. The SSP has also ordered a probe into the allegations levelled against Patel Nagar Police, assigning SP Rural Jaya Baluni to conduct the inquiry. In addition, the investigation into the robbery case itself is being handled by the Sahaspur Police Station SHO.
Police officials have also pointed out that another video allegedly released by absconding accused Aditya is being circulated on internet media. According to the SSP, the claims made in that video are also being examined and all aspects of the matter will be investigated thoroughly.
Meanwhile, the controversy has rapidly expanded beyond the robbery case and evolved into a debate on custodial conduct and police accountability. Digital platforms have witnessed intense discussions, with some users demanding a judicial or independent inquiry into the torture allegations, while others have cautioned against drawing conclusions solely on the basis of unverified videos circulating on social media. Several posts have questioned whether the suspension of the constable might have a chilling effect on other personnel who may come forward with allegations against senior officers. On the other hand, supporters of the police maintain that disciplinary norms apply equally to all personnel and that conclusions should await the outcome of the official inquiry.
The most pertinent questions, however, remain unanswered. If the constable’s alleged statements are found to be authentic, will investigators thoroughly examine the allegations against Naresh Rathore? Was any form of illegal coercion or custodial torture used during interrogation of the accused? Why has the most visible action so far been the suspension of the constable whose video surfaced? Most importantly, will the inquiry address the alleged torture claims with the same urgency as the disciplinary proceedings initiated against the constable?






